Tony® Award

• Best Actor in a Musical (1996) - Nominee
• Outstanding Book of a Musical (1996) - Winner
• Best Featured Actress in a Musical (1996) - Nominee
• Best Musical (1996) - Winner
• Best Direction Of A Musical (1996) - Nominee
• Best Featured Actor in a Musical (1996) - Winner
• Best Lighting Design (1996) - Nominee
• Best Original Score (1996) - Winner
• Best Actress in a Musical (1996) - Nominee
• Best Choreography (1996) - Nominee

Pulitzer Prize

• Pulitzer Prize for Drama (1996) - Winner

Drama Desk Award

• Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical (1996) - Winner
• Outstanding Lyrics (1996) - Winner
• Outstanding Actor in a Musical (1996) - Nominee
• Outstanding Orchestrations (1996) - Winner
• Outstanding Musical (1996) - Winner
• Outstanding Costume Design (1996) - Nominee
• Outstanding Actress in a Musical (1996) - Nominee
• Outstanding Music (1996) - Winner

New York Drama Critics Circle Award

• Best Musical (1996) - Winner

Theatre World Award

• Outstanding Debut Performance (1996) - Winner
• Outstanding Debut Performance (1996) - Winner

Outer Critics Circle Award

• Best Off-Broadway Musical (1996) - Winner